Pencil: Urban Decay 24/7, Almay
Gel/creme: Stila smudge pot (contrary to the name, after drying IT DOES NOT BUDGE), L’oreal HIP
*Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Eyeliner is my favourite gel liner. Maybelline does a good drugstore version but there are fewer colour choices.
*Chanel and Laura Mercier do great cake liners.
*MAC Liquidlast and the version by GOSH just don’t quit – longest lasting liners I know of, but the liquid texture/effect isn’t for everyone.
*I tend to find waterproof/long-wearing pencils smudge, but Prestige and Revlon Colorstay would be my picks.
*Of the more traditional eye pencils, Illamasqua Medium Pencils are fab.
Any eyeliner will last longer if you go over the line with a powder eyeshadow in the same colour. Eyeshadow primer underneath makes a big difference too. Urban Decay’s is brilliant for oily lids (which are often a cause of smudging).posted about 4 years ago
a lot of people have said urban decay 24/7 eye pencil.. honestly, ive tried every type of eyeliner out there ( including urban decays, which i used twice and probably wont use again. ) what can i say, i am a total eyeliner junkie!! anyways, ive tried all the department store brands, and i ALWAYS go to back to NYC’s (New York Color’s) Waterproof Eye Pencils. theyre like, 4 bucks at a drugstore. and most people would assume they suck. but ohmygosh, theyre amazing!! i highly recommend them, theyre only 4 dollars, what have you got to lose? =]posted about 4 years ago
Milani’s liquid ones (the ones in the tube with the gold end?) don’t budge all day! And Wet n’ Wild’s cream eyeliner in the little pot is great too, just use a seperate brush and not the one it comes with :x I use a Sonia Kashuk one and it lasts all day :)posted about 4 years ago
for pencil, almay is the only pencil i’ve tried so far that doesn’t SMUDGE throughout the day on my very oily, asian eyelids. plus it’s drugstore.
i also like milani’s liquid liners.
Hot Topic Black Pencil
I’m super-allergic to makeup and this does not irritate me in the least. AND, it stays on forever!posted about 4 years ago
i really like milani’s eye tech liquid eyeliner, it’s really short so that it’s easy to apply, and lasts all day. as for gel ones i like mac’s fluidline in blacktrack :)posted about 4 years ago
there are tons of great products out there, but we do love our lashionista modelista liquid liner- foolproof application with a touch of shimmer to add some glamour. its a two-in-one product that doubles as a mascara- perfect for the girl on the go!posted about 4 years ago
Almay 16-hour long-stay eyeliner, same with the revlon colorstay pencil eyeliner, for liquid eyeliner i like loreal’s lineur intense the best.posted about 4 years ago
Bobby Brown gel eyeliner. Sonia Kashuk for Target makes a similar one as well :-)posted about 4 years ago
I love MAC gel eyeliners and SEPHORA waterproof kohl and liner for pencil..posted about 4 years ago
I use Maybelline’s eyeliner, the one that’s in the small jar, I don’t remember the name.posted about 2 years ago