I bought this dress last year, but they have an updated version available for this summer.
comfort: plus points for having seam pockets! (I wish all dresses had pockets)
durability/material quality: The material is good, and I have washed it without anything weird happening to the unique texture. I own this in white and it's not see-through.
craftsmanship: My only caveats are that the pockets are visible on the white dress (you can see the solidness where the pocket linings lie) and the straps were a bit far apart, so I had to be very careful about bra-straps.
style: In terms of style, it's very simple and everyday chic, like J. Crew tends to be. It's perfect summer-wear. Perfect for a beach party or a hot summer gathering.