I would get frustrated with eyeshadow products because they did not give me the smokey, black eyes that I wanted. They appear to be gray or tend to smudge. Not until I used an E.L.F. eyeshadow set in black, gray and white. Just apply an eye primer before using, you're set and beautiful for a girls' night out! :D
In my experience E.L.F (eyes lips face) cosmetics has some really good products! I especially love some of their studio line brushes you can get online. The only products I've tried from them that I haven't liked are their eyeshadows. They are only $1 to $3, and definitely worth a shot!